Thenflation

Prices › Bakery & Pantry › Peanut butter

Price of peanut butter by year, 1980–2025

The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics hasn’t published an average price for peanut butter since December 2017, when it was $2.48. In 1984, the first year BLS published, it averaged $1.49, or about $4.84 in today’s dollars. Had it moved with the CPI for fats and oils since then, it would cost about $3.62 in October 2026 (our estimate).

Creamy peanut butter, per lb · U.S. city average · last published: December 2017

Yearly averages, plus the estimated latest month. Dashed stretches are estimates. “Today’s dollars” adjusts each year’s price for inflation (CPI-U, October 2026).
In 1990, a pound of peanut butter cost $1.89 on average. That’s about $4.88 in today’s dollars. Our estimate for Oct 2026, $3.62, is 26% less than the 1990 price after inflation.

Key facts

These facts use only years with published BLS prices.

Price of peanut butter by year

Average of the monthly prices published for each year. Rows marked “estimate” are Thenflation estimates, not BLS figures. The last monthly price BLS published was $2.48 (December 2017).
YearAverage priceIn today’s dollarsChange
2025estimate$3.61$3.78−1%
2024estimate$3.65$3.93+3%
2023estimate$3.56$3.94+9%
2022estimate$3.27$3.77+18%
2021estimate$2.76$3.44+5%
2020estimate$2.63$3.43+1%
2019estimate$2.60$3.43−1%
2018estimate$2.62$3.52+3%
2017$2.55$3.51−1%
2016$2.58$3.63−4%
2015$2.68$3.82+3%
2014$2.60$3.71−5%
2013$2.73$3.96−2%
2012$2.78$4.09+33%
2011$2.09$3.14+3%
2010$2.03$3.14−4%
2009$2.12$3.34+4%
2008$2.03$3.18+13%
2007$1.79$2.91+5%
2006$1.71$2.860%
2005$1.71$2.96−6%
2004$1.81$3.23−6%
2003$1.92$3.52−2%
2002$1.96$3.68+1%
2001$1.95$3.72+3%
2000$1.89$3.70+4%
1999$1.82$3.69+1%
1998$1.80$3.73+1%
1997$1.78$3.74−1%
1996$1.79$3.85−1%
1995$1.80$3.99−3%
1994$1.85$4.21+1%
1993$1.84$4.30−5%
1992$1.94$4.67−10%
1991$2.15$5.33+14%
1990$1.89$4.88+4%
1989$1.81$4.93+1%
1988$1.79$5.11−1%
1987$1.80$5.35+12%
1986$1.60$4.93+4%
1985$1.54$4.83+3%
1984$1.49$4.84+6%
1983estimate$1.40$4.74+1%
1982estimate$1.38$4.83−3%
1981estimate$1.42$5.27+11%
1980estimate$1.28$5.24—

About this data

Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Average Price Data, series APU0000716141 (“Peanut butter, creamy, all sizes, per lb. (453.6 gm)”, U.S. city average), retrieved from FRED, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.

Yearly figures are the average of the monthly prices published for that year. A year needs at least 9 monthly prices. “Today’s dollars” multiplies each year’s price by the change in the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers (CPI-U, U.S. city average, not seasonally adjusted) from that year to October 2026.

Rows marked “estimate” (12 of 46 years) are Thenflation estimates, not BLS figures. They fill the years without enough published prices, so the game and this page cover every year since 1980:

The October 2026 price is an estimate too: the 2025 estimate, moved with the CPI for fats and oils.

How the estimates work: About Thenflation.

More from Bakery & Pantry

Think you know what things cost?

Play today’s Thenflation